You pull into the lot the way you always do, cash ready for parking, kids already arguing about who gets to carry the bag. Except this year the bag looks different. At Apple Dave's, the bushel bag that's carried three generations of Warwick families out of the orchard has been swapped for something smaller: a half-peck or a peck, one-eighth and one-quarter of a bushel, respectively.
That's not one orchard having an off year. It's the visible edge of a freeze that hit the whole valley back in April, and it's rewriting how apple season works in Warwick this fall in ways that have nothing to do with foliage or crowds and everything to do with how much fruit actually survived on the branch.
The Freeze Happened in April, Not October
Warwick's apple season usually runs on a predictable clock: trees bloom in spring, fruit sets through summer, and by Labor Day the orchards open more or less on schedule. This year, an unusually warm early spring pushed apple and peach trees into bloom ahead of normal, and then a hard freeze moved through at exactly the wrong moment. The damage wasn't uniform. It depended on elevation, on variety, on how exposed a given block of trees was that night. Some orchards came through with most of their crop intact. Others lost the bulk of it.
That unevenness is the part worth sitting with, because it means the difference between a full harvest and a thin one in Warwick this year often comes down to a few hundred feet of elevation or which side of a hill a farm sits on, not anything the farm did wrong.
Same Ten Miles, Two Different Seasons
Pennings Farm, which has grown apples in Warwick since the family shifted away from dairy farming decades ago, took one of the harder hits. A third-generation family member, Tori Pennings Cosimano, put the apple loss at roughly 70 to 80 percent and the peach loss even higher, around 85 to 90 percent. In a Vision Times report, she described the apple crop as central to the business, saying, "the apple crop is so much more of our identity and the base of the business." The farm is adapting by leaning harder on pick-your-own strawberries, flowers, and vegetables, and by supplementing with apples sourced from other orchards.
A few miles away, Masker Orchards opened its 113th harvest season on September 5 running the exact same model it always has: $49.95 per car, a half-bushel bag holding roughly 22 pounds, no reservation required, seven days a week into early November. Warwick Valley Winery & Distillery, home to Doc's Cider, is similarly advertising its full slate of more than 60 apple varieties on its usual late-August-to-mid-November calendar at $40 per half-bushel bag.
Outside the village proper, the same split shows up. Soons Orchards in New Hampton lost most of its apples to the freeze and sharply cut back its usual U-pick schedule.
Comparing Bag Sizes and Admission Models
Pricing and admission models vary among Warwick orchards. Comparing them shows different ways to pick apples this season, but a bag size or admission format alone does not show how much fruit an orchard lost in April.
A quick comparison makes the pattern visible:
| Orchard | This Year's Model | What It Signals |
|---|---|---|
| Masker Orchards | $49.95 per car, half-bushel bag (~22 lbs), no reservation, full season | Operating on its usual schedule |
| Warwick Valley Winery & Distillery | $40 per half-bushel bag, 60+ varieties, normal late-Aug to mid-Nov season | Business running on its usual calendar |
| Apple Dave's | Half-peck ($15) and peck ($30) bags, replacing the usual bushel sizes | Offering smaller bags than usual |
| Pennings Farm | 70-80% apple crop loss reported, supplementing with sourced apples and other pick-your-own crops | Reported crop losses and a changed product mix |
Reading the pricing this way turns an ordinary Saturday errand into a small comparison of how Warwick orchards structure a visit this season, which is a more useful thing to know than which orchard has the better hayride.
What This Means for the Next Few Saturdays
The local outlet the Warwick Valley Dispatch spent time this season comparing prices and policies across orchards precisely because the sticker price alone doesn't tell a family what the outing will actually cost or include this year. Their bottom-line advice for 2026 was blunt: "Go while the apples are there." That's a real departure from the usual Warwick rhythm, where families wait for peak color in mid-to-late October and assume the trees will still be full when they arrive.
This year, waiting is a real gamble. A variety that's available on a Friday afternoon may be gone by Sunday at farms working with a reduced crop. Pennings still requires reservations on peak weekends to guarantee entry to its cidery and Orchard East, a policy that matters more this year given the tighter supply. Masker, by contrast, needs no reservation at all and is running its normal seven-day schedule, which makes it a lower-friction option if you're trying to avoid the guesswork.
Tuesday, September 15 brought Taste of Warwick, the Chamber of Commerce's annual fall food and beverage event, to Warwick Valley Winery & Distillery. Held on the winery grounds, it came just as the orchard season was settling into its rhythm. And however this season plays out, Applefest still lands on its usual date, the first Sunday of October, drawing the village's biggest single-day crowd of the year. Whether the orchards you visit that weekend still have much left to pick depends entirely on which side of April's freeze line they landed on.
None of this changes what makes Warwick worth living in. It's a small, useful reminder that even the most familiar local rituals run on conditions most of us never think to check until the bag in our hands looks different than it did last year.
If a Saturday in the orchard has you thinking more seriously about calling Warwick home rather than just visiting it for the weekend, Jennifer Loprieno at JPL Signature Homes knows this valley block by block, harvest by harvest. Let's Connect when you're ready to talk about what living here actually looks like, twelve months a year.